Exclusive Video
‘Are You My First?’ Sneak Peek: Colton Underwood Shocks the Cast With a Big Question (VIDEO)
Who could forget when Colton Underwood revealed that he… had not “do[ne] the damn thing” leading up to Fantasy Suites during Becca Kufrin‘s season of The Bachelorette?
In Swooon‘s exclusive preview of Are You My First?, hosted by the The Bachelor Season 23 lead and The Bachelorette Season 11 lead Kaitlyn Bristowe, Colton looks back at his time on The Bachelorette and pops a major question, leaving the entire Are You My First? cast questioning everything they know about the new reality show.
Hulu’s newest reality TV show, Are You My First?, features a group of singles looking to find love through romantic dates, challenges, and more. The catch? All 21 cast members, who are between the ages of 24 and 34, have never had sex. At least, that’s what both the cast and viewers thought — until now.
In the preview above, Colton shares that hosting Are You My First? is a “pretty personal” experience. He tells the cast, “When I first started looking for love on The Bachelorette, I was just like all of you: a virgin.” He continued, “If I’m being honest, the pressure of being a virgin made my time so much more difficult.”
According to the Bachelor Nation alum, his personal experience of letting the general public into his (lack of a) sex life through reality TV inspired him to ask the Are You My First? cast members right off the bat if they were all on the same page. He questioned, “Is everyone here really a virgin?”
To our surprise, all 21 of the “virgin” castmates stayed silent, looking at their peers to see who would respond first. Leading Rachael, a 30-year-old cocktail waitress from Tampa, Florida, to wonder if the real virgins in the cast had been lied to. In a confessional, she asked, “Wait, what? I hope everyone here is a virgin… That’s kind of the whole point here. I want to be with a virgin.”
Do you think the Are You My First? cast contains any secret non-virgins? Comment below with your reaction to this wild cliffhanger!
Are You My First?, Series Premiere, August 18, Hulu
