[Warning: The below contains MAJOR spoilers forLove Island: All StarsSeason 3, Episodes 1-9.]
Love Island wouldn’t be Love Island without its bombshells testing the bonds of the current couples. In the case of Love Island: All Stars, the franchise has the opportunity to create even more drama with its new additions to the villa, since it can pull from the pre-existing pool of former Islanders. It’s common for the spinoff to reunite exes or throw in Islanders with histories of stirring the pot.
Love Island: All Stars Season 3 has quite a ways left to go, but it’s wasted no time in throwing new contestants into the mix. On Day 9, the return of two new Islanders marked their fourth appearances in the franchise. One starred inLove Island Games a few months ago, while the other competed in Love Island: All Stars Season 2.
So, what familiar faces have shown up so far? Swooon has all the latest updates on the bombshells in the villa. Let us know which ex-Islanders you’re hoping make a comeback in the comments at the end of the page!
Love Island: All Stars, Season 3, Every Day, Peacock
Love Island / Instagram
Curtis Pritchard (Day 9)
Past season(s): Love Island UK Season 5, Love Island Games Season 1, Love Island: All Stars Season 2
After splitting with his All Stars ex Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu in May 2025, Curtis is back for round four of Love Island. The reality TV vet, who entered with his sights set on Islanders Samie Elishi and Millie Court, said, “I normally throw all my eggs into one basket… I’m probably going to end up doing that again.”
“I like to focus on one person,” he added. “I’ve never been a bombshell before, so I don’t quite know what to expect coming in as one. I’ll try and talk to everyone the first couple of days.”
loveisland / Instagram
Lucinda Stafford (Day 9)
Past season(s): Love Island UK Season 7, Love Island Australia Season 5, and Love Island Games Season 2
Only a few months after winning Love Island Games Season 2 alongside Isaiah Campbell, Lucinda is back in the villa. From the outset, she mentioned Ciaran Davies as one of the guys she’s interested in. Now that she’s older, the Islander said she’s going to approach things with more confidence.
“I guess I’ve been on a bit of a Love Island journey over the past few years, but I’ve not found the ultimate one,” Lucinda explained. “I’m single, so having been given the opportunity to try and find a guy on Love Island: All Stars, why would I say no?”
Love Island / Instagram
AJ Bunker (Day 4)
Past season(s): Love Island Season 7
AJ Bunker doesn’t have a very extensive Love Island background. During Season 7, AJ competed alongside fellow current All Star Millie, but she was dumped after only a handful of days. The 33-year-old hair extension technician and boxer began her All Stars journey by kissing Ciaran Davies in the Hideaway.
Love Island / Instagram
Konnor Ewudzi (Day 4)
Past season(s): Love Island Season 11
After first appearing on screens in 2024, Konnor is back in the game. The 30-year-old model and rugby player made a splash right away at the first recoupling ceremony. Konnor revealed that he had a bit of a past with fellow bombshell AJ: They kissed in a club and had messaged each other afterward. Regardless, Konnor has his sights set on Millie, whom he stole from Charlie Frederick. Konnor doesn’t have a serious villa ex from Season 11. He was dumped from the villa alongside Lolly Hart, but they decided not to pursue anything.
Love Island / Instagram
Samie Elishi (Day 4)
Past season(s): Love Island Season 9 and Love Island:All Stars Season 2
Samie is a Love Island regular. She reached the finals in 2023 with Tom Clare, but didn’t get far when she returned for All Stars in 2025. The 25-year-old estate agent coordinator-turned-influencer split with Tom soon after Season 9 ended.
loveisland / Instagram
Scott van-der-Sluis (Day 1)
Past season(s): Love Island Season 10, Love Island USA Season 5, and Love Island Games Season 1
The only Islander that has Samie beat in terms of franchise appearances is Scott van-der-Sluis. Back in 2023, he had back-to-back stints on the show. He has history with fellow Love Island alum Catherine Agbaje, though they didn’t pursue a relationship. He didn’t find a connection during his brief time on Love Island USA and Love Island Games.
He plans on All Stars Season 3 being his last time on the show, and he seems to have a go big or go home mindset. As soon as he stepped foot in the villa, he dragged Sean, calling him “one of the worst Islanders [he has] seen.” Ouch.