90 Day
Who Won the ’90 Day: Hunt for Love’ Season 1 Tell All? (POLL)
Sure, 90 Day Fiancé Tell Alls aren’t a competition, but that doesn’t mean no one comes out on top.
TLC’s newest 90 Day show, 90 Day: Hunt for Love, wrapped up its first-ever Tell All on September 1 with one of the most dramatic Tell Alls in franchise history, bringing together fan-favorite 90 Day alums, their singles’ resort connections, and other key players for the 90 Day universe to discuss everything that went down in Tulum and beyond.
At the end of the Hunt for Love Tell All Part 2, Colt Johnson finally put to words the unspoken reason behind the tension on the Tell All stage: Every 90 Day Tell All is a competition. Looking back at his time on the stage, Colt told viewers, “I feel like this Tell All went very well. People feel, like, nicer towards me because of my [injured] leg, almost. I kind of won out of this whole thing.”
Taking into consideration Colt’s stipulation that someone could “win” the Tell All, we decided to put his theory to the test by looking back at the performance of all eight 90 Day alums on Hunt for Love. Scroll to find out the highs and lows of each star on the Tell All, and be sure to vote for the star you think won the Tell All!
Tiffany Franco
Throughout Hunt for Love, Tiffany was caught in multiple love triangles. While she ended up with Rocky Russo in Tulum, she had broken up with him by the time of the Tell All. Today, she has a boyfriend named Ronnie.
High: Put Carlo on blast for continuing to text her after picking someone else.
Low: Revealed that her new boyfriend has the same name as her ex.
Jeniffer Tarazona
Jeniffer survived an entire summer in Tulum with her ex, Tim, and still managed to find love at the resort. As of the Tell All, she is still dating her 90 Day: Hunt for Love co-star Cole Anderson. However, seeing as Cole found out that she hooked up with Rob Warne during their time in Tulum, it’s unclear whether they are still together today.
High: Surprised her costars by revealing she is still dating Cole.
Low: Stormed off when asked if she had sex with Rob at the resort.
TLC
Usman Umar
90 Day Fiancé‘s very own Soja Boy may not have returned from Tulum with a partner, but he still had plenty to say about his costar’s connections at the Tell All.
High: Made his plans to get married this year very clear, even though he does not have a girlfriend (yet).
Low: Would not stop talking about Colt’s penis. No, really. What was up with that?
Tim Malcolm
Even though Tim shared Usman’s fate of leaving Hunt for Love alone, the costars found little common ground at the Tell All. After his spat with Usman and a guest appearance by his close friend/ex Vanessa, Tim made a move on one of his costars.
High: Scored a post-Tell All date with 90 Day newbie Elise Benson.
Low: Smacked the TV broadcasting Usman.
TLC
Cortney Reardanz
Turns out, Cortney and Colt are still together, even though Cortney admitted that she still talks to her other connection, Usman. As of the Tell All, Cortney still lives with Colt at her parents’ house.
High: Admitted that she and Colt are in love.
Low: Claimed that Colt either has erectile dysfunction or isn’t attracted to her.
Colt Johnson
Colt Johnson took a mighty fall during Season 1 of Hunt for Love, but if you ask him, he would do it all again. The 90 Day vet left the Tell All with Cortney by his side, claiming he won the entire thing.
High: Cortney defended his manhood, so to speak.
Low: Was put on blast by the full cast for still living with Cortney’s parents.
Rob Warne
Rob is another Hunt for Love cast member who did not leave the resort with a love connection. However, the 90 Day star was able to keep his cool while still spilling tea on the Tell All stage.
High: Minded his own business when it came to his hook-up with Jeniffer at the resort.
Low: Revealed that his ex-wife, Sophie Sierra, is seeing Chantel’s ex-husband, Pedro Jimeno.
TLC
Chantel Everett
The Family Chantel shocked everyone by choosing to pursue her close friend, Ashley, instead of any of her castmates in Tulum. At the Tell All, both Chantel’s mom, Karen, and Ashley joined the cast on stage.
High: Shared a steamy kiss with her girlfriend, Ashley.
Low: Her mom lowkey stole the spotlight.
90 Day: Hunt for Love, Season 1, Streaming Now, HBO Max
