Catch Her If You Can
Tessa Bailey
Contemporary Romance • Sports Romance
Published: January 20, 2026
3 of 5 on the
Spice Meter
Hotshot Yankees catcher Madden Donahue has been in love with Eve Mitchell since high school, but she’s always turned him down. When Eve’s sister leaves Eve with her two children for the foreseeable future, Madden offers to marry her so she can receive health benefits. Turns out, Eve has always had feelings for Madden, too, but her best friend called dibs on Madden when they were teenagers. This marriage starts out as one of just convenience, but the long-held feelings between Madden and Eve turn this arrangement into something more, something that could possibly last forever.
TropesFake DatingFriends to LoversSecond Chance
What Swooonies Are Saying
Have you read Catch Her If You Can? Leave a quick review and let us know what you think with a star rating on a scale of ⭐ to ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐.