Where Is Cassie Randolph Now? All About Colton Underwood’s Ex & Her Life Today
What To Know
- Former Bachelor star Colton Underwood is currently appearing on The Traitors Season 4.
- His final rose recipient was Cassie Randolph, who is now married.
- Cassie Randolph’s sister, Michelle, is a prominent TV star.
Former Bachelor star turned Are You My First? host Colton Underwood has quite the impression on The Traitors. Now that it’s clear the Season 4 faithful is here to stay (at least for now), we’re looking back at his season of The Bachelor, a.k.a that one time he jumped a fence after his soon-to-be final rose recipient self-eliminated.
From the first few episodes of The Bachelor Season 23, it was clear that the “Virgin Bachelor,” Colton Underwood, was head over heels for speech pathologist Cassie Randolph. At the end of the season, Randolph told Underwood that she was leaving the competition because she felt unready to get engaged after her hometown date. That’s when the infamous camera punch and fence jump happened. (Watch that wild scene below!) Once Underwood returned to production, the producers told him they were able to bring Randolph back, and the two left the show as boyfriend and girlfriend.
Now that Colton Underwood has returned to our screens on The Traitors, and fans are looking back at his season of The Bachelor, Swooon‘s breaking down everything you need to know about Cassie Randolph’s life now.
Is Cassie Randolph in a relationship today?
Yes, Randolph is in a relationship with musician Brighton Reinhardt. While fans began to speculate that there was something going on between Randolph and Reinhardt, whose family is friends with Randolph’s, just a few months after she split from Underwood in 2020, the couple did not go Instagram official in July 2021.
On a 2022 episode of Kaitlyn Bristowe‘s Off the Vine podcast, Randolph revealed, “He’s a great person. It’s very, like, natural. So easy. Which I never understood until this [relationship].” The couple got engaged on November 25, 2024, in Newport Beach, California.
Jesse Grant / Getty Images
When was Cassie Randolph’s wedding?
Randolph married Brighton Reinhardt on Friday, December 5, 2025. The two had an intimate ceremony in Costa Rica at The Point Luxury Villa with 70 family members and friends in attendance. At the time, Randolph told People, “It feels so rare to get everyone to pause their lives, travel somewhere beautiful, and just be together. I couldn’t wait to look around and see our closest friends and family all in Costa Rica, celebrating with us and making memories we’ll talk about forever.”
Who is Cassie Randolph’s sister?
Romance fans may also recognize Cassie Randolph’s sister, Michelle Randolph, who stars as Ainsley in the hit Paramount+ series Landman.
She was recently cast opposite The Summer I Turned Pretty star Christopher Briney in the upcoming holiday comedy Clashing Through the Snow. Off-camera, Michelle has been spotted with Chad Powers star Glen Powell multiple times, sparking speculation that they may be an item. Asked about how she feels about dating publicly after her sister’s Bachelor breakup, Michelle Randolph shared, “Ironically, I think I’ve learned that I want to keep it private.”
Why did Cassie Randolph and Colton Underwood break up?
In May 2020, Randolph and Underwood called their relationship quits due to differences in lifestyle choices. A source told People, “Ultimately, Colton and Cassie just weren’t on the same page. Colton really wanted to settle down and get married — he’s been ready for a long time. And Cassie just wasn’t ready. They both knew it wasn’t going to work.”
Months later, Randolph filed a restraining order against Underwood on September 11, 2020. In the court documents, she accused Underwood of “stalking” and “harassing” her between June and August 2020. On November 3, 2020, Randolph dropped the charges against Underwood, who told E! News, “The two of us were able to reach a private agreement to address any of Cassie’s concerns.”
Underwood came out as gay in April 2021. During his Good Morning America interview, Underwood apologized to his ex. “I would just say that I’m sorry from the bottom of my heart,” he said. “I’m sorry for any pain and emotional stress I caused. I wish it wouldn’t have happened the way it did. I wish that I would have been courageous enough to fix myself before I broke anybody else.”
The former NFL player has since married Jordan C. Brown. They welcomed their son, Bishop, via surrogate in 2024.
The Traitors, Season 4, New Episodes Thursdays at 9/8c, Peacock
The Bachelor, Season 23, Streaming Now, Prime Video
